Claim: “Average U.S. water damage insurance claim is $15,400 (2019–2023, Insurance Information Institute)”
This figure is widely republished and attributed to the Insurance Information Institute, but it does not appear in Triple-I's published data. Triple-I's table is “Average Homeowners Losses, 2018-2022” (source: ISO, a Verisk business), and its table archive contains no 2019-2023 edition. The water damage and freezing row reads $13,954.
Verified figure: $13,954 average claim severity, 1.61 claims per 100 house years, 2018–2022.
Trend: 2016–2020 $11,650 → 2017–2021 $12,514 → 2018–2022 $13,954.
Possible origin: The same Triple-I table lists “All property damage” at $15,570 average — one row below the water damage line. A misread of that row is a plausible origin, though we cannot confirm it.
How we checked: Retrieved the raw HTML of the Triple-I homeowners facts page and searched it directly; “15,400” returns no match, “13,954” does. Cross-checked against Triple-I's table archive listing every historical edition.
Check the primary source yourself