Skip to main content

Serving US homeowners

Homeowner choosing a water damage restoration company while an insurance claim is open
insurance guide

Can I Choose My Own Water Damage Restoration Company? Yes, and Here Is What the Insurer Can Still Require

7 min readUpdated 2026-10-12

Quick answer

Yes. A homeowners policy pays for covered repairs; it does not choose the contractor, and the work contract is between you and the company you hire. Insurers may offer a preferred-vendor program (State Farm's is voluntary and carries a five-year workmanship warranty), and Louisiana and Tennessee write the right to choose into statute. The insurer can still ask for an itemized estimate, photos and drying logs, and a chance to inspect before the rebuild. Start drying the same day with whoever you pick. Call (864) 806-2818 to reach a certified water damage restoration company in your area; the line is answered 24/7.

Enter your 5-digit ZIP when asked. The line goes quiet for about half a minute while it connects — that is normal, stay on. If it does not connect, call once more: companies taking calls change minute to minute.

Marcus Reed

Written by Marcus Reed

Reviewed by Elena VargasLicensed Public Adjuster (TX, FL, LA)

Reviewed October 12, 2026· Next review Apr 2027

The claims representative took your report, gave you a claim number and the name of a restoration company "we work with." You already have one in mind, or you found one that can be at the house in an hour, and you want to know whether saying no to the insurer's suggestion costs you anything. In nearly every case it does not. What follows is what the policy actually promises, what a preferred-vendor program is and is not, the states that have written the right to choose into law, what the insurer can still require of the company you pick, and exactly what to say on the phone.

The Policy Pays. It Does Not Pick.

A homeowners policy is a promise to pay for covered damage. It is not a promise to repair it, and it does not name a contractor. The District of Columbia's insurance regulator states the arrangement directly in its guide to restoration claims: the homeowner may select a contractor suggested by the insurance company but is not required to do so, and the contract for the work will always be between the homeowner and the contractor. Washington's Office of the Insurance Commissioner says the same thing from the other direction: the insurer may suggest a list of contractors or preferred providers it has worked with before, but you have the right to select your own contractor, and the company is not even required to give you a list.

Two consequences follow. The insurer is responsible for paying for the covered repairs, not for the availability of contractors or delays in their work; Washington's regulator says so in as many words. And because the contract is yours, the company works for you, which is exactly the point of choosing it.

What a Preferred-Vendor Program Is

Many carriers run one, under names like managed repair, direct repair or network provider. The structure is similar enough that one example will do. State Farm's Select Service program describes itself as a customer choice program made up of network service providers who manage contractors for roofing, water mitigation, smoke cleaning, general contracting and flooring. Three details on its own page matter to you:

  • It is voluntary. The claim handler decides whether a claim qualifies, and you opt in.
  • It carries a five-year workmanship warranty from the network provider, and 24-hour response for water mitigation.
  • You may use the independent contractor or service provider you prefer; the program's benefits apply only if you stay inside it.

So the trade is real, and it is yours to make.

Insurer's network companyCompany you choose
Who hired themYou, from the insurer's programYou
PricingHandled inside the programXactimate line pricing, reconciled with the adjuster
Workmanship warrantyProgram warranty (State Farm's is five years)Whatever the company offers in writing
Estimate approvalOften quicker; the adjuster already knows the companyNormal supplement process
Scope disagreementsResolved inside the programYou and the company push back on the adjuster's scope

The network company is not a bad choice; it is a convenient one. The reason to go outside it is a company you trust more, that can arrive sooner, or whose careful work you have already seen. Franchise or local company covers that comparison.

States That Put the Right in Writing

A few states have gone beyond regulator guidance and written the choice into statute. Two you can check today:

  • Louisiana. The claims statute says an insurer shall not require that repairs, replacement, restoration or remediation be made by a particular preferred vendor or recommended contractor when paying a residential or commercial property claim, and an insurer that recommends one must tell you that you are under no obligation to use it (La. R.S. 22:1892(E)).
  • Tennessee. On a homeowners structural claim with an estimated value of $20,000 or more, the insurer must give you a written statement of your rights, including the right to have repairs made by a contractor of your choice, with the contractor understood to be hired by you (Tenn. Code 56-7-125).

Elsewhere the rules vary by state. Most insurance departments publish a homeowners claim guide, and the Washington and District of Columbia guides quoted above are typical of what they say. If your insurer tells you that using your own company will affect the claim, ask for that in writing and send it to your state insurance department.

InfographicWater damage cost per square foot, by water category

per sq ft, mitigation only

  • Category 1Clean supply water
    $3–$7
  • Category 2Grey water
    $4–$8
  • Category 3Black water
    $7–$15

Extraction and drying only. Rebuilding drywall, floors and cabinets is priced separately.

The mold clock on wet material

  1. Hour 0Water stopsShut the supply and start getting water out. Drying begins here.
  2. About 24 hSpores germinateMold spores start growing on wet drywall, carpet pad and wood.
  3. 48–72 hVisible coloniesGrowth you can see and smell. Drying becomes a mold job.
Serving US homesCertified US companiesCall nowLine answered 24/7
HearthDry
Step by step4 steps

How to Use Your Own Restoration Company on an Insurance Claim

  1. 1Start mitigation with the company you chooseStop the water, photograph everything, and get certified extraction and drying started before anyone inspects.
  2. 2Tell the claims line who is doing the workCall the same day with the claim number and the company's name.
  3. 3Match the estimate to the adjuster's scope of lossHave the company estimate in the same line-item format the adjuster uses, compare the two line by line, and send missing items back as a…
  4. 4Keep the contract in your nameSign a mitigation-only work authorization at a stated price basis and, if useful, a direction to pay.
Line answered 24/7Talk to a certified company near youCertified companiesNo referral chargeVisit our websitehearthdry.com
HearthDry is a referral service, not a contractor.
Call now: (864) 806-2818Enter your 5-digit ZIP when asked · No charge for the referral
Works directly with adjusters

Need a contractor your insurer accepts?

Claims live or die on documentation. Crews that estimate in Xactimate and log moisture readings give adjusters what they need.

(864) 806-2818
  1. Describe the loss and where the claim stands
  2. You're routed to a crew that documents for insurers
  3. They scope it in writing — you decide, no obligation

What the Insurer Can Still Require

Choosing the company does not remove the insurer from the process. It can reasonably ask for the following, and a good restoration company produces all of it without being asked.

The insurer can requireWhy
An itemized estimateThe adjuster prepares a scope of loss; your company's estimate should be in the same line-item format so the two can be reconciled.
Local market pricingMost carriers and contractors price in Xactimate, from a regional list for your ZIP. The argument is rarely the unit price; it is what is included.
Photos, moisture readings and drying logsThis is the evidence that the loss was sudden and that the work was needed.
A chance to inspect before permanent repairsMitigation starts at once; the rebuild usually waits for the adjuster's visit or written agreement.
Receipts for emergency workKeep every one; emergency payments are part of the settlement.
Proof the company is licensed and insuredAsk for the certificate of insurance and the license number before work starts.

What it pays is its scope of loss at its approved price, not any invoice a contractor writes. The District of Columbia guide tells homeowners to make sure the contractor uses that scope as the work plan, and that is sound advice wherever you live: if your company's estimate is higher, the difference is settled by supplement, with photos and readings attached, not by handing the invoice to the adjuster and hoping. How to read an Xactimate estimate explains the format, and the claim guide covers supplements.

How to Tell the Insurer You Have Hired Someone

  1. 1Start mitigation with the company you choose. Do this first. Your policy requires you to protect the property from further damage, and wet drywall and subfloor are on a 24–48 hour clock before mold begins. Nobody's permission is needed for extraction and drying.
  2. 2Tell the claims line who is doing the work. Call the same day. Give the claim number, the company's name, the fact that mitigation is under way, and ask three questions: whether the adjuster wants to inspect before anything beyond drying begins, where to send the estimate and drying logs, and whether the insurer will pay the company directly on a direction to pay.
  3. 3Match the estimate to the adjuster's scope of loss. When the scope arrives, sit down with the company and compare it to their estimate line by line. Missing items go back as a supplement with evidence. Documenting water damage lists what the file needs.
  4. 4Keep the contract in your name. Sign a work authorization for mitigation at a stated price basis, and a direction to pay if you want the insurer to pay the company directly. Decline anything that assigns your policy benefits to the company; it changes who controls the claim.

A sentence that works on the call: "Mitigation has started with [company], an IICRC-certified firm I hired. Their estimate and drying logs will come to you under claim number [X]. Do you need to inspect before we move past drying?"

Where This Usually Goes Wrong

  • Treating the insurer's name as an order. It is a suggestion. The regulators quoted above say so.
  • Treating the contractor's invoice as the claim. The claim is the adjuster's scope plus whatever you supplement with evidence.
  • Choosing a company that will not share its logs. If the moisture readings stay on the technician's tablet, your supplement has no proof.
  • Signing the rebuild with the drying crew on day one. Mitigation and reconstruction are separate decisions; how to choose a restoration company covers the second one.
  • Accepting a deductible waiver. A company offering to absorb your deductible has to make it up somewhere, and that somewhere is the invoice to your insurer. Restoration scams lists the rest.

If You Have Not Chosen a Company Yet

The right company is one with IICRC water restoration certification on the crew, a license and insurance certificate it will show you, a mitigation-only authorization at a stated price basis, and a habit of sending its readings to adjusters. Who to call for water damage sets out the order of calls.

(864) 806-2818 is answered 24/7 and connects you to an IICRC-certified water damage restoration company taking calls in your ZIP; there is no charge for the referral. Enter the 5-digit ZIP of the property, then stay on through about half a minute of quiet while it connects. The company you reach is one you have chosen; nothing about the referral changes who holds the contract or the claim.

Serving US homesCertified US companiesCall nowLine answered 24/7
HearthDry
PIPE BURST OR LEAKAT HOME?

Water moves fast. What you do first decides if it stays a drying job.

Do this first

  • Shut off the mainNear the meter or where the line enters.
  • Kill power to wet roomsFlip the breaker before you step in.
  • Photograph everythingBefore you move or throw anything out.
Line answered 24/7Talk to a certified company near youCertified companiesNo referral chargeVisit our websitehearthdry.com
HearthDry is a referral service, not a contractor.
Call now: (864) 806-2818Enter your 5-digit ZIP when asked · No charge for the referral

Reading to confirm what you already suspect?

Confirm it in two minutes instead — the pro on this line answers questions about YOUR situation all day: what it is, what it should cost, whether you even need service. If you want, they'll set the appointment on the same call.

Toll-free · no obligation · asking costs nothing

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I have to use the restoration company my insurance company recommends?

NoState insurance regulators in Washington and the District of Columbia both say the homeowner may choose any contractor, and that the insurer's suggestion is only a suggestion.

The insurer pays for covered repairs under the policy; the contract for the work is yours. If a claims representative says otherwise, ask for it in writing and check it with your state insurance department.

Can my insurer deny the claim because I used my own contractor?

A covered loss does not become uncovered because of who dried it. What the insurer can do is pay its own scope of loss rather than your contractor's invoice, ask for an itemized estimate, photos and moisture logs, and insist on inspecting before permanent repairs.

In Louisiana, an insurer is barred by statute from requiring a particular vendor at all. Keep the drying documentation and the gap is settled by supplement.

What is a preferred vendor program?

A network of contractors the insurer has vetted and manages, sometimes called managed repair or direct repair.

State Farm's version is a voluntary customer choice program: the claim handler decides whether the claim qualifies, the network provider gives a five-year workmanship warranty, and the policyholder may still use any contractor they prefer. The convenience is real; so is the fact that the contractor works inside the insurer's program.

Will the insurer pay my contractor's full invoice?

It pays the adjuster's scope of loss at approved pricing, which may be less than the invoice. The difference is handled by a supplement: the contractor submits the missing line items with photos and drying readings, and the adjuster approves or disputes them.

The District of Columbia's regulator advises homeowners to have the contractor use the scope of loss as the work plan for exactly this reason.

Who pays the restoration company, me or the insurance company?

You are the customer, so the contract and the bill are yours, and the insurer reimburses the covered part under the policy.

Many companies accept a direction to pay, which tells the insurer to make the check for the approved amount payable to the company so you are not fronting the money. The deductible and anything outside the approved scope stay with you.

What do I say to my insurance company when I hire my own company?

Give the claim number, the company's name, and the fact that mitigation has already started.

Then ask whether the adjuster wants to inspect before work moves past drying, where to send the estimate and moisture logs, and whether the insurer will pay the company directly. Put the same information in an email to the adjuster so the file shows the date.

Can I start the work before the adjuster has inspected?

Extraction and drying, yes, and your policy expects it: you have a duty to protect the property from further damage, and wet materials start growing mold in 24–48 hours.

Photograph everything first and keep receipts. Permanent repairs such as new drywall or flooring are different; most insurers want to inspect or agree the scope before those begin, so ask on the first call.

Who do I call right now for water damage?

Call (864) 806-2818. The line is answered 24/7, and connects you with an IICRC-certified water damage restoration company that serves your area. A recorded prompt picks up first: key in your 5-digit ZIP code, and hold through the short silence while the call is passed to the company.

Describe what you can see — where the water is coming from, how long it has been there, and whether it smells — the more specific you are, the faster the right company is on the line. If the source is a pipe or an appliance, shut the main water valve first. Have four things ready and the call goes quickly: the address, when the water started, what is wet now, and whether you have filed an insurance claim.

Still not sure which of these is your situation? (864) 806-2818 · toll-free · answered 24/7

Sources

  1. Washington Office of the Insurance Commissioner — Hiring a general contractor for homeowner insurance claims
  2. DC Department of Insurance, Securities and Banking — Hiring a contractor after a homeowners claim
  3. State Farm — Select Service home repair program
  4. Tennessee Code 56-7-125 — Policyholder's right to choose a contractor (FindLaw)
  5. Louisiana Revised Statutes 22:1892(E) — Insurer may not require a preferred vendor (Justia, 2025)

Methodology: How we source and verify data · Report an error

Disclaimer: HearthDry is an independent educational resource. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute professional, legal, or insurance advice. Consult licensed professionals before making decisions about your property or insurance claims.

Free 2-day shipping

Amazon Prime members pay no shipping on restoration equipment

Dehumidifiers, air movers, and moisture meters qualify for free Prime delivery — bulk items that otherwise cost $15–$40 to ship.

Try Prime free →

Affiliate link — HearthDry earns a bounty if you sign up; costs you nothing extra.

Advertisement

Choice Home Warranty — Covered Home Repairs On Us

Can't Talk Right Now?

Send your details and we'll follow up by email. If water is still coming in, the line is faster — is answered 24/7.

By submitting you agree that we may contact you about your water damage. No spam. No obligation.

24/7 Emergency Response

We connect you with pros available around the clock — nights, weekends, and holidays.

IICRC-Certified Pros

Referrals go to restoration professionals working to IICRC standards (S500 water, S520 mold).

Ask for License and Insurance

Referred contractors are expected to hold state licensing and liability insurance — ask for both before work starts.

No-Obligation Consultation

Call anytime. Describe the damage, get pointed at the right trade, decide afterwards.