Quick answer
Neither brand wins on its own, because both are franchise systems that send a local owner: SERVPRO, founded in 1967, lists more than 2,400 US and Canadian locations, and Paul Davis, dating to 1966 and owned by FirstService, lists more than 300 franchises built around emergency work plus reconstruction. Both estimate in Xactimate. The choice that matters is whether one company dries and rebuilds; either way, sign mitigation separately so the rebuild can be bid once the house is dry. Call (864) 806-2818 to reach a certified water damage restoration company in your area; the line is answered 24/7.
Enter your 5-digit ZIP when asked. The line goes quiet for about half a minute while it connects — that is normal, stay on. If it does not connect, call once more: companies taking calls change minute to minute.
Written & reviewed by Marcus ReedIICRC WRT
Reviewed October 12, 2026· Next review Apr 2027
A homeowner weighing SERVPRO against Paul Davis is rarely choosing between two brands in the abstract. More often an adjuster has named one of them, a neighbor used the other, and the ceiling is still dripping. The two companies tell different stories about themselves: SERVPRO leads with its size and round-the-clock emergency service, Paul Davis with the rebuild that follows the cleanup. Both are franchise systems, so the business that signs your paperwork is a local owner in either case. The decision that actually changes your outcome is narrower and more practical: should the company that dries your house also be the one that rebuilds it, and if so, on what terms. This guide puts the brand facts side by side, then works through that decision.
The Two Brands on Paper
Everything below comes from each company's own pages, read on October 12, 2026.
| SERVPRO | Paul Davis | |
|---|---|---|
| Origin | 1967, Sacramento, California, as a painting business owned by Ted and Doris Isaacson | 1966, as Paul Davis Systems |
| Franchising | First franchise sold in 1969 | A network of independently owned and operated franchises |
| Headquarters | Gallatin, Tennessee | Jacksonville, Florida, with its national training center |
| Size, by its own count | More than 2,400 locations in the US and Canada | More than 300 franchises in the US and Canada; a franchise page cites more than 1,000 estimators and 1,300 project managers |
| Ownership | Blackstone acquired a majority stake in March 2019 | Parent company is FirstService Corporation |
| How it describes its work | "24/7 Emergency Services"; the history page does not describe reconstruction | Emergency restoration, reconstruction and remodeling; says it pioneered "the Insurance Restoration Contractor" category |
| Who does the work | "Independently owned and operated franchises of Servpro Franchisor, LLC" | "Each Franchise Office Independently Owned and Operated" |
Two rows deserve a second look. The size row says SERVPRO has roughly eight times as many locations, which mostly affects whether there is an office near you and how much spare capacity exists when a cold snap bursts pipes across a whole metro. The description row is the real difference in emphasis: Paul Davis presents itself as a company that cleans up and then rebuilds, and a Paul Davis franchise page describes the brand as one of the first restoration networks to "meld restoration and remodeling." SERVPRO's history page, by contrast, does not describe reconstruction, so ask the local SERVPRO office directly whether it rebuilds in house, subcontracts, or hands that part off.
Neither brand's history page names IICRC certification for its crews. That is not a mark against either, since certification belongs to people and firms rather than logos, but it means the certification check is yours to run on the office that shows up.
Why the Logo Decides Less Than the Local Owner
A SERVPRO office in your county and a Paul Davis office in your county are two separate small businesses. Each has its own owner, its own technicians, its own equipment and its own reputation, and either brand's national website tells you nothing about which of the two is better run. Both systems estimate in Xactimate, the pricing database insurers use, so a square foot of drywall removal or a day of dehumidifier rental prices about the same in the same ZIP whichever van is in the driveway. When two estimates for the same house differ by thousands, the gap is scope: what one estimator tears out that the other dries in place, how many equipment days each plans, and whether the rebuild is folded into the same document. The Xactimate guide shows how to read those line items, and the franchise versus local guide explains what a franchise standardizes and what it leaves to the owner.
For the brand-level pictures, the SERVPRO cost guide covers how SERVPRO offices price water work, and the Paul Davis reviews guide covers what customers report about that brand's offices.
The Real Decision: One Company or Two
Restoration has two halves. Mitigation is the emergency part: extraction, removing what cannot be saved, and structural drying until the materials reach a dry standard. Reconstruction is everything after that: new drywall, paint, flooring, cabinets and trim. Paul Davis openly sells both halves as one service. A SERVPRO office may or may not. Either way, you choose whether to keep both halves with one company.
| One company dries and rebuilds | Drying and rebuild split | |
|---|---|---|
| Accountability | One contract and one project manager from first extraction to final paint | Two contracts; a gap can open between the dry-out and the start of the rebuild |
| Records | Moisture logs and photos stay with the builder | You carry the drying records to the rebuild contractor yourself |
| Price check on the rebuild | None unless you ask for it; the rebuild is priced by the same estimator who set the demolition | The rebuild is bid by contractors who did not decide how much came out |
| Incentive to watch | The company that removes more material also gets more rebuild work | The drying company has no rebuild work riding on demolition |
| Who it suits | Owners who want one point of contact and trust the office's scope | Owners who want to compare the rebuild price or use their own contractor |
Neither column is wrong. Keeping both halves together is convenient and is a normal way to run an insured job. The protection is the same in both columns: sign the mitigation scope on its own, so keeping the rebuild with the same company is a choice you make once the house is dry rather than a clause you signed on the first night.
The Four Steps
- 1Decide whether one company should dry and rebuild. Use the table above. If the adjuster recommended one of these brands through an insurer program, note that the recommendation is not a requirement. Washington's insurance commissioner, to take one regulator, states that you have the right to select your own contractor, and adds that when you use the contractor your insurer chooses, the insurer should stand behind that work. Your state's rules may differ, so check your policy and your state insurance department.
- 2Sign a mitigation-only work authorization. Whichever office starts, the first signature should cover extraction, removal of unsalvageable material and drying, and nothing else. Read it for an assignment of benefits, which hands your claim rights to the contractor; the restoration scams guide explains why that clause deserves a slow read.
- 3Get the drying documentation before demolition. Ask for a moisture map on day one and daily readings after that, with each removal line tied to a reading. Structural drying is billed by the equipment day, and the structural drying cost page shows what those days cost.
- 4Bid the rebuild once the house is dry. When the office reports the dry standard has been met, ask it for a separate reconstruction estimate, and get at least one more from another licensed contractor working from the same drying records. If the first office's rebuild price holds up, keep it; it may well be the easier path.
per sq ft, mitigation only
- Category 1Clean supply water
- Category 2Grey water
- Category 3Black water
Extraction and drying only. Rebuilding drywall, floors and cabinets is priced separately.
The mold clock on wet material
- Hour 0Water stopsShut the supply and start getting water out. Drying begins here.
- About 24 hSpores germinateMold spores start growing on wet drywall, carpet pad and wood.
- 48–72 hVisible coloniesGrowth you can see and smell. Drying becomes a mold job.
Serving US homesCertified US companiesCall nowLine answered 24/7
How to Choose Between a SERVPRO and a Paul Davis Office
- 1Decide whether one company should dry and rebuildWeigh one contract and one project manager against a rebuild price nobody else has checked.
- 2Sign a mitigation-only work authorizationThe first signature covers extraction, removal of unsalvageable material and drying only.
- 3Get the drying documentation before demolitionAsk for a moisture map on day one and daily readings, with each removal line tied to a reading.
- 4Bid the rebuild once the house is dryAsk the drying office for a separate reconstruction estimate and get at least one more from another licensed contractor working from the…
Already have a quote? Compare it
National brands price from a franchise rate card. A local IICRC-certified crew often scopes the same job differently — you keep whichever quote is better.
(864) 806-2818- Tell them the scope you were quoted
- A local certified crew prices the same work
- Compare line by line — no obligation either way
What to Ask Each Local Office
| Ask | A good answer |
|---|---|
| What is your legal business name and state license? | A name you can look up in the state contractor registry, active, matching the estimate |
| Who leads my job, and what is their IICRC number? | A named technician holding WRT for water or AMRT for mold, which you can check in the IICRC locator |
| Do you rebuild in house or subcontract it? | A straight answer, with the subcontractor named if there is one |
| Can I sign for mitigation only? | Yes, on a separate authorization |
| How will you prove the house is dry? | A moisture map, daily readings and a written dry standard |
| Are you on my insurer's program, and what changes if you are? | An explanation of who reviews the scope and how payment flows |
| Will you bill my insurer directly? | Direct billing or a direction to pay, explained before you sign |
The IICRC certifications guide explains what each credential covers. An office that answers these with documents is showing you its scope is a diagnosis. One that answers with the brand name is telling you something too.
If you have run these questions past both offices and still want a third, independent scope before you sign anything beyond the drying, (864) 806-2818 is answered 24/7 and connects you to an IICRC-certified water damage restoration company taking calls in your ZIP; there is no charge for the referral.
What the Work Costs With Either Brand
Because both price from Xactimate, the national ranges do not change with the logo. Water mitigation runs about $3–$7 per square foot for clean water, $4–$8 for gray water and $7–$15 for contaminated water. With reconstruction included the figure rises to roughly $10–$25 per square foot, which is why the one-company-or-two decision carries real money. Most residential water incidents land between $2,000 and $6,000 all in, and mold remediation runs $1,500–$12,000 depending on how far it has spread. A rebuild that is bid separately can only move the reconstruction share of that bill, but on a finished basement or a kitchen it is often the larger share.
Where Each Brand's Shape Shows Up
- Coverage. With more than 2,400 locations, SERVPRO is more likely to have an office close by, and sometimes several. Paul Davis's 300-plus franchises are spread more thinly, so some areas may not have one nearby.
- The rebuild handoff. Paul Davis builds its pitch around carrying a job from emergency service to finished room. If you value that continuity, ask the SERVPRO office how its own handoff works before assuming it matches.
- Insurer relationships. Both brands work with insurance carriers, and Paul Davis describes the insurance-restoration model as its origin. A program relationship can speed paperwork; it does not take away your right to compare scopes.
- Capacity. In a regional event, a larger network has more neighboring offices to borrow crews from. Ask either office what happens to your job if its crews are stretched.
None of these outweighs a failed license check or a scope with no moisture readings behind it.
If the House Is Still Wet Tonight
Do not let the comparison hold up the drying. Stop the water at the main shutoff, photograph every wet room before anything is moved, and let whichever qualified office can start begin under a mitigation-only authorization. Mold can begin on wet materials within 24–48 hours, and comparing rebuild bids can wait for a dry house. If neither local office answers or passes the checks above, (864) 806-2818 reaches a certified restoration company covering your area: enter your 5-digit ZIP, and stay on through about half a minute of quiet while it connects. The SERVPRO alternatives guide lists other franchises and the independent option if you want more names to check.
Serving US homesCertified US companiesCall nowLine answered 24/7
Water moves fast. What you do first decides if it stays a drying job.
Do this first
- Shut off the mainNear the meter or where the line enters.
- Kill power to wet roomsFlip the breaker before you step in.
- Photograph everythingBefore you move or throw anything out.
Reading to confirm what you already suspect?
Confirm it in two minutes instead — the pro on this line answers questions about YOUR situation all day: what it is, what it should cost, whether you even need service. If you want, they'll set the appointment on the same call.
Toll-free · no obligation · asking costs nothing
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Paul Davis better than SERVPRO?
Not as a brand, and SERVPRO is not better than Paul Davis either. Each system is a set of separately owned offices, and the gap between two offices of one brand is usually wider than the gap between the brands.
Judge the two offices near you on their state license, the lead technician's IICRC number, an insurance certificate and a written, room-by-room scope tied to moisture readings.
Is Paul Davis Restoration a franchise?
YesIts About page describes a growing network of more than 300 independently owned and operated franchises in the United States and Canada, with headquarters and a national training center in Jacksonville, Florida.
The parent company is FirstService Corporation. The office that comes to your house is a local franchisee, so its own license and its crew's credentials are what to verify.
Does Paul Davis do reconstruction after water damage?
YesReconstruction and remodeling appear on Paul Davis's own service list next to water, mold and fire work, and one franchise page says the brand was among the first to combine restoration and remodeling.
Whether a given office builds with its own staff or uses subcontractors varies, so ask before you sign the rebuild.
Does SERVPRO do reconstruction?
SERVPRO's history page talks about its founding, size and 24/7 emergency service but does not describe rebuilding work.
Whether a particular office rebuilds with its own staff, subcontracts the work or leaves it to you once drying ends is a question to put to that office directly. Either way, get the reconstruction price as a separate document from the drying.
Should the same company do mitigation and reconstruction?
It can, and it often makes life simpler: one contract, one project manager, and the drying records stay with the builder. The trade-off is that nobody else prices the rebuild.
Keeping the authorizations separate lets you decide after the house is dry, when you can compare a second rebuild estimate written from the same moisture records.
My insurer recommended Paul Davis. Do I have to use them?
In most states, no. Washington's insurance commissioner, for example, says insurers may suggest preferred providers but you have the right to select your contractor.
Rules and policy wording vary, so read your declarations page and check your state insurance department. A program contractor can be a perfectly good choice; you just keep the right to compare its scope.
Which is bigger, SERVPRO or Paul Davis?
SERVPRO, by its own count: more than 2,400 locations against Paul Davis's more than 300 franchises, both read on October 12, 2026. A Paul Davis franchise page also cites over 1,000 estimators and 1,300 project managers across its offices.
Size affects how likely an office is to be nearby and to have spare crews during a regional freeze, not how well the nearest office is run.
Who do I call right now for water damage?
Call (864) 806-2818. The line is answered 24/7, and connects you with an IICRC-certified water damage restoration company that serves your area. A recorded prompt picks up first: key in your 5-digit ZIP code, and hold through the short silence while the call is passed to the company.
Describe what you can see — where the water is coming from, how long it has been there, and whether it smells — the more specific you are, the faster the right company is on the line. If the source is a pipe or an appliance, shut the main water valve first. Have four things ready and the call goes quickly: the address, when the water started, what is wet now, and whether you have filed an insurance claim.
Still not sure which of these is your situation? (864) 806-2818 · toll-free · answered 24/7
Sources
- SERVPRO — Our History
- Paul Davis — About Us
- Paul Davis Restoration & Remodeling of Fox Valley WI — Why Paul Davis
- IICRC — Global Locator for certified firms and technicians
- Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner — Filing a homeowner insurance claim
Methodology: How we source and verify data · Report an error
Disclaimer: HearthDry is an independent educational resource. This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute professional, legal, or insurance advice. Consult licensed professionals before making decisions about your property or insurance claims.
Free 2-day shipping
Amazon Prime members pay no shipping on restoration equipment
Dehumidifiers, air movers, and moisture meters qualify for free Prime delivery — bulk items that otherwise cost $15–$40 to ship.
Affiliate link — HearthDry earns a bounty if you sign up; costs you nothing extra.
Equipment
What each machine actually does
Removes the moisture the structure is still giving off — the machine that decides how long drying takes
See the picks →Moves air across wet surfaces so the dehumidifier has something to take out of the air
See the picks →Finds water behind walls and under floors, and tells you when a material is actually dry
See the picks →Alerts you the moment a leak starts; a small cost, and the one preventive item here
See the picks →Those pages carry affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, HearthDry earns from qualifying purchases; it costs you nothing extra.
Our Amazon storefront →
